Why do judges have so much power

Explore intellectual conservatism Join a vibrant community of students and scholars Defend your principles. Plus, The 50 best books of the 20th century, the case to bring back single-sex spaces, and Wordsworth on the power of habit. Plus, the Left's latest plan to take over education: Critical Media Literacy, and how to get canceled with dignity. Notice: JavaScript is required for this content. Skip to content.

Why so complicated? Why must the law emanate from the legislature? The view that judges cannot make law is increasingly unpopular. Get the best of intellectual conservatism. Every Thursday. Get the Collegiate Experience You Hunger For Your time at college is too important to get a shallow education in which viewpoints are shut out and rigorous discussion is shut down.

Explore intellectual conservatism Join a vibrant community of students and scholars Defend your principles Join the ISI community. Membership is free. You might also like. What Happened to the Boy Scouts?

One senator wants to know whose side the nominee would be on in disputes between corporate and consumer interests, between polluters and protecting the environment, or between insurance companies and average Americans. But these comments actually arose during the debate over the nomination of John Roberts to be Chief Justice of the Supreme Court.

And they expose one side in the debate over how much power judges should have. The Left views the judicial branch as no different from the executive or legislative branches. They separated the three branches so that government power would be limited; the Left today tries to blur those boundaries so that government will be more powerful. This is what the debate over the Kavanaugh nomination is all about. How much power are unelected judges supposed to have in our system of government?

The notion that the Constitution means whatever five members of the Supreme Court want it to mean is as radical as it is indefensible. When he became a judge on the U. The other view was expressed by Senate minority leader Charles Schumer D. Leave a Reply Cancel reply.

Facebook Twitter Youtube. Is there any evidence supporting this? Angela Gracie on Was the Republican Party created to abolish slavery? Angela Gracie on Would you like to see George Floyd commemorated on a stamp?

Laura on Would you like to see George Floyd commemorated on a stamp? Rachel Johanson on Do you think Ghislaine Maxwell should be allowed bail? Bella Rossi on Alone with Trump in an Elevator. Two polar opposite stories about Trump from two women who met him in person. Recent Posts Are more people moving away from liberal cities or conservatives cities?

Is Candace Owens running for Vice President? Was the police shooting of Walter Wallace Jr. Is it okay that Democrats are hoping the president dies of covid? Is Black Lives Matter a political party?

Do you think Ghislaine Maxwell should be allowed bail? Defund the Police? How About We Defund the Universities.